Why not yes? (or at least maybe)
August 21, 2007Let me start with a quick disclaimer. I am proud of Aurora Public Schools and absolutely love what I do. At the same time, I am also one of those people that truly believes there is always room for improvement.
I am amazed by how many times the kids are told that they can’t do this or that these days when it comes to technology in our schools. It seems like they can’t do anything anymore. I don’t know about you, but no becomes frustrating to me after a while. What exactly is the reason behind all of these nos? It is simply “because I said so”, “because those are the rules”, or “because that’s the way it’s always been done?” Are the nos there because there just isn’t that surface level understanding of how powerful all this technology can be? Just a thought.
There is one particular school in our district that demonstrates this point pretty well. On one visit, all I hear is security monitors yelling at kids to take the iPods out of their ears. No iPods in school. No.
During another visit, I learn more about the cell phone policy. First offense, parents need to come get the phone. Second offense, Saturday school. Third offense is a suspension. How does the punishment fit the crime? What’s the connection? And why no?
The visit that sticks in my mind the most is my afternoon in this particular school’s media center. The first thing I see is laminated pieces of paper on every single computer in the room with a big red stop sign on them. Kids aren’t allowed to use the computers until they turn in their student IDs. Not paticularly inviting or welcoming to start with. And I’m also positive there are plenty of other rules and regulations that limit the students in what they can do when they eventually get onto the computers as well. Every student that walks in to the media center the day I’m there is told “no” to every question they ask. “Can I get on the internet?” No. “Can I get my student ID so I can get on the internet?” No. Not for at least a few more days. The equipment is not working. I guess the staff is also “getting the lab ready” too, but I see nobody hard at work at any of the many computers there. Who’s owning the learning, access, and information here? School has been in session for a couple of weeks already and the kids can still do pretty much nothing. There’s not one student in the lab that is set up specifically for student access. When there’s no kids around it definitely doesn’t feel like a school, it’s just a bunch of computers sitting there.
What if yes? What if kids could come in a create their own spaces on MySpace (no, I can’t make a link to that page because our district blocks it), Second Life (blocked again…no. Isn’t that kind of ironic!?), a blog, or a wiki? Alan November said, “We need to get over the fear in this country.” Every student that walks into that media center is viewed as a potential hacker, inappropriate page searcher, settings changer, and the list goes on and on. Sure there are some kids that will choose to do that, but it’s our job to monitor that and have appropriate consequences for the kids that make these types of choices. But it seems like after all, it’s just easier to say no in the first place.
What if every kid was seen as a powerful resource? What if every student was seen for their positive technological and academic potential? What if that kid on their cell phone was calling and/or text messaging a teacher or a classmate to make sure they did the right assignment for class today? What if kids are listening to their teacher’s lecture from yesterday on their iPod so they are more prepared for today’s class? What if they were listening to a podcast they found on iTunes that they knew would support them in their upcoming class, exam, or standardized test? What if that was the type of environment you helped to create in your school?
We are 100% positive with the results we’ll get when we say no. That’s what makes no so comfortable sometimes. But what might the results look like if we simply said yes? I’m not talking about just blindly saying yes to everything, that wouldn’t make sense. But just think about it from the perspective of your students. Get to know more about their world. Think of the potential that’s available with the knowledge and tools that are simply second nature to them in their reality.
Enough already with the nos; why not yes? Or, at the very least, reevaluate why you’re saying no. Perhaps we could change some of those nos to maybes. That would be a step in the right direction. You might be surprised at what you might find out about your students and how passionate they can be about school and learning. They might even show you a thing or two. Who would own the learning then?
Posted by Jay Vean
